Sorry I’m a little behind in posting the winner, it’s been a rough week, but more on that next blog post. The winner is…not me, or Anderson, who made it in for Thanksgiving. We were skunked by a seven-year-old, who won this year’s Annual Cutthroat Tunno Pumpkin Pie Competition. He even fluted the crust!
It was my great-nephew Alessandro, who took the kids trophy last year. He got the most first place votes. My great-nephew Nate came in second (that’s him on the phone) and my nephew Chris came in third.
Alessandro has learned everything he knows from my nephew Patrick, a fabulous cook himself. I’ve seen photos of this child at three or four standing on a step-stool so he could reach the stove top to stir. Patrick learned quite a bit about cooking from living in Italy for several years and is the author of A Guide to Italy, Cultural Insights and Tips to Maximize your Trip. (Yes, that’s what’s called a plug and you should buy it if you or a friend are planning a trip to Italy. It’s very helpful.)
And every year I learn more than I ever wanted to about pumpkin pie.
- When you’re tasting seven pies, one after another, the sugar can get to be too much, so less sugar is better. You don’t need 3/4 of a cup of sugar in one pie even if Libby’s says you do. I just changed my Prize Winning Pumpkin Pie recipe to 1/2 cup and it should be great. Please try it and let me know.
- I now have what I consider the perfect combo of liquid ingredients: evaporated milk, cream and half and half.
- Leave out the cloves. They make the pie gritty. If you must use cloves, then try clove extract (which I didn’t even know existed until I Googled it just now). Or get out a mortar and pestle and make sure your ground cloves are a powder, or your pie will be gritty. I cannot abide grit in anything I eat. It stops me cold.
- Whipped cream makes every pumpkin pie better. Vanilla ice cream works incredibly well too.
- Repeatedly going back to make sure your vote was correct and actually eating the pie is a very bad idea, especially after consuming your weight in turkey and all the side dishes. Next year, I’m bringing a spit cup like the professional tasters do. No offense family pie bakers.
- There is a new recipe from Libby’s using sweetened condensed milk, which was also very good, but again, a little too sweet.
- My family learned the art of competition from my mom who used to try to bribe my nephews with dollar bills to say her pie was the best. I think, once again, she would be proud to know that the contest.
If you enjoy this blog, stories and the recipes and would like to be a supporter so I can stay caffeinated enough to turn out a blog on a regular basis, just click on buymeacoffee.com/FranTunnoAnd please feel free to share and become a follower by entering your email in the box on the top right if you’re on a computer, or the bottom if you’re on your phone. And Thank You!

