There, I said it. In fact, I am a total ho for fall. I positively glow in autumn light. I embrace pumpkin spice and dismiss all of you who mock it. (But Starbucks, please take note: One pump of pumpkin spice is plenty in any coffee drink, three is overkill and way too sweet.)
I take daily photos of my favorite leaves and send them to my kids. My phone just told me I have 700 plus photos of leaves in it’s memory. I am including my favorite leaf of all time because it blew me away two years ago with its perfect colors.
My favorite leaf.
I had a thought last week looking out at the gorgeous leaves dazzling us on their way out. Wouldn’t it be great if when we died, we went out like leaves, in an amazing blaze of color, looking our most spectacular and making everyone oooh and awwww? Plastic surgeons might not like it, but I think it would be cool.
This week ends with Halloween and I will be making my annual chuck roast feast. Don’t hate me vegan friends, I only cook this once a year and I’m making it for Carolyn, who’s throwing a Halloween party.
A goth pumpkin from the Pittsburgh Zoo.
I make it every year in honor of Mrs. Santelli. She lived down the street from our house. I remember standing in her doorway on a chilly Halloween night waiting for her to bring candy, and smelling the most amazing aroma of beef cooking in wine (at least that’s what I think I remember). So, when I got older I wanted to recreate that smell for my kids to remember every Halloween. And they do.
This year it will be accompanied by creamy mashed red potatoes, and roasted butternut squash for Carolyn’s soiree. I don’t have a costume yet but do have an old sheet I could cut some eyes out of if things get desperate.
Mostly, I’m writing this to remind you of a recipe I posted about four years ago when I was working as a temp at Carnegie Mellon. I baked a cake I’d kept a recipe for, for more than 20 years (procrastination is my super power). It was amazing! Everyone raved about it. It is definitely worth sharing, not only as a Halloween recipe but as a Thanksgiving dessert alternative to pumpkin pie.
It’s moist pumpkin cake covered with butterscotch frosting…how can you possibly go wrong with this??? You can’t! Trust me it’s that good! So, today, I’m giving you two recipes, one is for the chuck roast, so you can make it for Halloween. It’s one of the recipes in Come on Down!A Little Story About My Italian Mom’s Big Dream. (It must be good if it made it into the book!) The other is for the pumpkin cake, from a blog post in 2021.
Preheat oven to 350. Remove meat from packaging. Rinse it and shake off excess water. Sprinkle it with meat tenderizer and poke it all over with a fork.
2
Crush the 2 garlic cloves and place them in a cast iron or heavy duty frying pan with 1 TBSP olive oil. Place the meat in the pan on top of the garlic and oil, and brown it on both sides. Remove it from frying pan and place it into an oiled roasting pan or Dutch oven.
3
After removing the meat from the frying pan, pour the wine in the pan and deglaze it, scraping up all the pieces of flour and garlic. Turn off heat and set the wine mixture aside.
4
Slice the three onions into 1/4 inch slices. Lay the onion slices over the top of the beef. Then pour the wine from the pan over the onions and meat. Cover pan with aluminum foil and bake for three hours or until meat is fork tender turning once while cooking.
5
Check the meat after three hours. Turn it over and spoon the onion wine mixture over the top. If the meat can be pulled apart easily, it's done. If not, replace the foil or Dutch oven lid and give it another 15 minutes to a half hour. Serve with the onion/wine gravy mixture on top of the meat. The gravy is great over mashed potatoes too!
Ingredients
1three pound boneless chuck roast
meat tenderizer (sprinkled lightly over roast)
2garlic cloves (crushed)
½cupflour (for dredging)
1tbspolive oil
3large red onions (sliced 1/4 to 1/2 inch thick)
⅓bottle of good quality Merlot or Cabernet
Pam spray or a thin coat of olive oil on pan
Directions
1
Preheat oven to 350. Remove meat from packaging. Rinse it and shake off excess water. Sprinkle it with meat tenderizer and poke it all over with a fork.
2
Crush the 2 garlic cloves and place them in a cast iron or heavy duty frying pan with 1 TBSP olive oil. Place the meat in the pan on top of the garlic and oil, and brown it on both sides. Remove it from frying pan and place it into an oiled roasting pan or Dutch oven.
3
After removing the meat from the frying pan, pour the wine in the pan and deglaze it, scraping up all the pieces of flour and garlic. Turn off heat and set the wine mixture aside.
4
Slice the three onions into 1/4 inch slices. Lay the onion slices over the top of the beef. Then pour the wine from the pan over the onions and meat. Cover pan with aluminum foil and bake for three hours or until meat is fork tender turning once while cooking.
5
Check the meat after three hours. Turn it over and spoon the onion wine mixture over the top. If the meat can be pulled apart easily, it's done. If not, replace the foil or Dutch oven lid and give it another 15 minutes to a half hour. Serve with the onion/wine gravy mixture on top of the meat. The gravy is great over mashed potatoes too!
In a large mixing bowl combine flour, baking soda, baking powder, salt, cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves and ginger. Stir well and set aside.
2
In a separate large bowl, combine softened butter with sugar and whip it together. (It may not be creamy, but will separate into very small clumps). Add the pumpkin and lightly beaten eggs. Mix it briskly. There will be small lumps that will disappear when baked. Stir in milk and mix again. Add dry ingredients and mix well.
3
Butter and flour a 9 x 13 inch baking pan. Bake at 350 degrees about 40 minutes, or until a wooden toothpick comes out dry and clean. Cover with foil so the moisture stays in when cooling. Once cool, spread with Butterscotch Frosting
Butterscotch Frosting
4
Combine sugar, butter and cream in a small heavy bottomed saucepan. Cook over medium heat, stirring constantly, until mixture is well-blended, 1-3 minutes. Remove from heat and whisk quickly to blend thoroughly. Set aside
5
Pour the combined sugar, butter and cream (which is now butterscotch sauce) into a large bowl and add 3 to 4 cups of powdered sugar until mixture is a good spreading consistency. I ended up adding 3 1/2, then I waited until it cooled a bit to see if the consistency was good for spreading. Add the salt to taste (and remember the best dessert recipes are a perfect marriage between sweet and salty so don't skimp on the salt!). Spread it on the cooled cake and enjoy!
Ingredients
3 ⅓cupsflour
2tspbaking soda
½tspbaking powder
1tspsalt
1tspcinnamon
½tspnutmeg
¼tspground cloves
½tspginger
⅔cupbutter
2cupsmashed pumpkin
4eggs (lightly beaten
2 ¼cupssugar
⅔cupmilk
Butterscotch Frosting
1cuplight brown sugar (not packed)
½cupbutter
½cupheavy cream
3cupspowdered sugar
¼tspsalt (or more - to taste)
Directions
1
In a large mixing bowl combine flour, baking soda, baking powder, salt, cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves and ginger. Stir well and set aside.
2
In a separate large bowl, combine softened butter with sugar and whip it together. (It may not be creamy, but will separate into very small clumps). Add the pumpkin and lightly beaten eggs. Mix it briskly. There will be small lumps that will disappear when baked. Stir in milk and mix again. Add dry ingredients and mix well.
3
Butter and flour a 9 x 13 inch baking pan. Bake at 350 degrees about 40 minutes, or until a wooden toothpick comes out dry and clean. Cover with foil so the moisture stays in when cooling. Once cool, spread with Butterscotch Frosting
Butterscotch Frosting
4
Combine sugar, butter and cream in a small heavy bottomed saucepan. Cook over medium heat, stirring constantly, until mixture is well-blended, 1-3 minutes. Remove from heat and whisk quickly to blend thoroughly. Set aside
5
Pour the combined sugar, butter and cream (which is now butterscotch sauce) into a large bowl and add 3 to 4 cups of powdered sugar until mixture is a good spreading consistency. I ended up adding 3 1/2, then I waited until it cooled a bit to see if the consistency was good for spreading. Add the salt to taste (and remember the best dessert recipes are a perfect marriage between sweet and salty so don't skimp on the salt!). Spread it on the cooled cake and enjoy!
Ok, that cake sounds amazing! Will try it, but am uncommited to the frosting. We are not really frosting people.Maybe a glaze… But, I digress. My mother’s chuck roast was strictly practical and I adored it. It included using a couple of packets of Lawry’s Onion Soup. The gravy was heaven over rice, because, Chinese. Thank you for the memories and I am off to see if they still make those packets undoubtably filled with chemicals and carcinogens. YUM.
I believe your lovely partner in crime is going to be making that pumpkin cake or cupcakes, so you will soon taste the yum. Can’t go wrong with butterscotch frosting!
7 Comments
Matilda
October 26, 2026 at 11:36 pmi Love Fall, and i Love that you are such a brilliant foodie!
Looking forward to trying Both of these!
Petrea
October 26, 2026 at 12:45 pmI love your idea of dying like leaves. I mean, if we must go, why not go out in glorious spectacle! I think it’s brilliant.
Fran Tunno
October 26, 2026 at 6:48 pmThat’s my plan! I’m good to wait to see it through though!
kendylyoung
October 26, 2026 at 12:16 pmOk, that cake sounds amazing! Will try it, but am uncommited to the frosting. We are not really frosting people.Maybe a glaze… But, I digress. My mother’s chuck roast was strictly practical and I adored it. It included using a couple of packets of Lawry’s Onion Soup. The gravy was heaven over rice, because, Chinese. Thank you for the memories and I am off to see if they still make those packets undoubtably filled with chemicals and carcinogens. YUM.
Fran Tunno
October 26, 2026 at 6:47 pmYes but chemicals and carcinogens can be so very tasty! Enjoy!
Rob
October 26, 2026 at 8:12 amYum, the pumpkin cake sounds even better than your pumpkin cookies I ate so many of last year.
Fran Tunno
October 26, 2026 at 11:01 amI believe your lovely partner in crime is going to be making that pumpkin cake or cupcakes, so you will soon taste the yum. Can’t go wrong with butterscotch frosting!